Choosing the Best Steak for Grilling

Choosing the Best Steak for Grilling

June 22, 2017 0 By John Thomas

Polar Plunge for Special Olympics MN TAILGATEMASTER.COM Admiral BigGun

steak on the grill

Look at the juices…. NOM NOM NOM

To begin, you need to understand the basics of the different cuts of beef and how to choose the right one. From there, we’ll get into how to cook it to your desired level of done-ness.

Choosing a Steak

Examining the butcher shop cases can be overwhelming. There are so many different cuts available—big steaks, skinny steaks, huge roasts, small roasts, and more. If your goal is to cook a good steak at home, I recommend sticking with the ribeye, T-bone, New York strip, or filet mignon. These are the most expensive cuts, but in steaks you get what you pay for and these are the most tender when grilled or pan fried. The differences in tenderness come from the cow having stability muscles (think the lower back), which are less powerful and thus tender, and load-bearing muscles, which are tough. Price is directly correlated to these qualities. A tender steak will cost a lot more than a tough steak (though with the right treatment, you can successfully turn a tough cut like brisket into a tender, flavorful meal).

If the sheer volume of beef cuts still overwhelms you, check out our easy-to-read guide to steaks and their tenderness, price, and ideal preparation.

different cuts of beef chart for grilling steak guide

Mmmmmm dead cow NOM NOM NOM!

The seasoning requirements differ based on the cut. A tougher steak requires more seasoning because your eating experience is mostly about tasting the seasoning, rather than enjoying the tenderness of the cut. For example, you can get away with simple salt and pepper on a perfectly cooked filet mignon, while a flank steak used for fajitas should have some sort of spicy rub all over.

Thanks to the folks at and John Thomas for sharing these tips and tricks!

For more Steak Tips and Tricks see 7 Tips for Making Flame Kissed Steaks .

For more grilling ideas click here.


*NOTE: DOES NOT receive any sort of payment-for-clicks for referring you to products that we review. If you find this information useful, please consider sharing our site with others. We have even included some handy social media buttons (below) to make it easy. Isn’t that swell of us?
OH, and if you feel like buying us a beer…